ADFS Greatest NFL QB of All Time Top 10 (#1 Voting)

[BNC]

Its a theoretic term. "Defense wins championships" by keeping the other guys from scoring. A team still cannot win without an offense that puts points on the board. Obviously the New England defenders aren't the persons throwing the ball to Gronk on Sundays.

I'm just saying, I don't like using team accomplishments to judge a player when a guy can QB a team to 40+ points and still lose the game and some other QB could put up 10 and win just because his teams defense is much better

 

[RunSoHard]

This isn't 1996 guys, I'll take Peyton over Brady debates all day but Montana is no longer "the guy." A culmination of stats, championships, influence on others, and supporting cast...it's no longer Joe. Sorry San Fran.

I'm assuming you're one of those who assume Joe just had Jerry Rice there his entire career. His best two receivers when he won his first two superbowls? Dwight Clark and Feddie Solomon. He had Jerry Rice for the last two but in '88 his 2nd receiver was Mike Wilson and got John Taylor in '89. They did have Roger Craig and a great defense, but the Pat's defenses when Brady won his first superbowls was amazing as well.

 

[Lynch Mob]

I'm assuming you're one of those who assume Joe just had Jerry Rice there his entire career. His best two receivers when he won his first two superbowls? Dwight Clark and Feddie Solomon. He had Jerry Rice for the last two but in '88 his 2nd receiver was Mike Wilson and got John Taylor in '89. They did have Roger Craig and a great defense, but the Pat's defenses when Brady won his first superbowls was amazing as well.

San Francisco always had better defenses. The Patriots have used offensive players in the secondary during Super Bowls. Look, there's no debating Montana's place in history and it's near the top. He's simply been passed up is all.

 

[RunSoHard]

Let's not forget that Brady should be 3-3 in Superbowls if the Seahawks ran the ball

 

[Lynch Mob]

It's a tough pill to swallow when our childhood icons are passed by today's super-neutered, pampered, effeminate, and sometimes gangster athletes.

 

[Howard4mvp12]

This isn't 1996 guys, I'll take Peyton over Brady debates all day but Montana is no longer "the guy." A culmination of stats, championships, influence on others, and supporting cast...it's no longer Joe. Sorry San Fran.

joe>brady

 

[Lynch Mob]

joe>brady

Compelling argument.

 

[Howard4mvp12]

only way brady can win another Superbowl ring, is by the giants not making it there.

 

[Lynch Mob]

only way brady can win another Superbowl ring, is by the giants not making it there.

icedragon...is that you?

 

[Howard4mvp12]

icedragon...is that you?

dude icedragon is the biggest pats fan , does it look like i like the pats ?

 

[cavsfan817]

I hate Tom Brady, but he's either 1a or 1b with Montana. Most likely 1a