- Thread starter
- #1
not only out of the cy young but also out of 4-6 wins via kyle mcllelan's utter suckness.Carp was robbed.
hmmm lets see it comes down to semantics for this award this year.I like Tim, and there's no doubt he deserves the CY Young, but I don't get why Carpenter didn't win it.
You could say that, but why should character issues have an impact on an award that is primarily based upon performance on the field?I think due to his drug bust, Tim should NOT have been considered.
That, and he has FUGLY long hair
well if you look at it that way, it does make more sensewithout this guy, the giants would have been even worse. without carpenter or wainwright, the cards would have still made the playoffs
The Giants still have Matt Cain who had a great year as well.i hate the giants, but tim definitely deserved it. quit hating some of you.
without this guy, the giants would have been even worse. without carpenter or wainwright, the cards would have still made the playoffs
this was actually super close. like flip a 3-sided coin.
no one should be mad at it except cards fans i suppose
A Cy Young candidate himself...Cain had a great season and I hope that continues.The Giants still have Matt Cain who had a great year as well.
If you couldn't tell Tim smoked, then I don't know what to say. Besides profiling, how does that make him any less of a phenominal pitcher? Just because he smokes weed doesn't make him less talented...he still went out there and performed like a deserving Cy Young winner didn't he? He might have even smoked on gameday...but I bet he still went out there and dominated those games. He should get an award for pitching impaired <_<I think due to his drug bust, Tim should NOT have been considered.
and a better w/l record....hmmm lets see it comes down to semantics for this award this year.
Tim had about 30 more IP, 1 more CG, Tim also had like 120 more K's, and his opppents BA was lower by like .15.
Carpenter did have a better ERA and WHIP.
But I can see where your coming from if you think Carp deserved it and I wouldnt disagree with you.