Hypothetical NL MVP Question

[elcheato]

5 homers is too much for him to make up against Pujols,

 

[snipezo]

He's been on fire as of late. Playing a lot in coors field helps a lot too.

 

[Mexi]

i dont care how hot he is, 5 HR is a lot for a month

but he does have more home games in september than road games, so he has an outside chance

seriously, his home/road splits are really drastic

 

[snipezo]

It's 4 now but it's w.e. Anything can happen.

 

[Mexi]

ok im done slighting Cargo

.340 leads
100 rbi leafs
32 HR is 3 behind

wow, what a season. no one on earth thought he'd be this good. wow.
especially since he was their leadoff hitter until Helton got hurt/struggled. then he was hot, so Tracy put him 3rd when Tulo also got hurt and BOOM

 

[elcheato]

I told you a while ago he was the best hitter in that division

 

[Mexi]

he's not
go look at his splits

give me Adrian all day
then Tulo
then Cargo
then Posey
then Ethier
then Upton

 

[elcheato]

He's close to winning the triple crown, I don't care about his splits

 

[Mexi]

can you imagine Adrian at Coors, with that line-up around him?

 

[elcheato]

I can't since he's on the Padres

 

[Mexi]

he's the best player in the division

 

[Yankees2772]

You can't say best... Because CarGo runs and plays great defense (well, Adrian plays D too) But CarGo has been the best player in the league this season, and the division too.

 

[Mexi]

1 season

Adrian doesnt have nearly the line-up or park Cargo has. shoot, he plays in the polar opposite of Coors

Cargo is sure on his way if he keeps doing this, but right now Adrian is still the best in the division

BUT, if i had to pick 1, i'd take Cargo. younger, more speed like you mentioned, and he plays a plus outfield. he could win a GG in all 3 positions. well i guess GG just picks 3 OF's, but you get what im saying.
I'll even ignore his home/road splits

actually, if i was able, i might take Tulo over both

 

[Elite]

CarGo is an animal. I've loved this guy since his A's days. He's one of the best, if not the best, 5-tool player in the MLB.

 

[elcheato]

1 season

Adrian doesnt have nearly the line-up or park Cargo has. shoot, he plays in the polar opposite of Coors

Cargo is sure on his way if he keeps doing this, but right now Adrian is still the best in the division

BUT, if i had to pick 1, i'd take Cargo. younger, more speed like you mentioned, and he plays a plus outfield. he could win a GG in all 3 positions. well i guess GG just picks 3 OF's, but you get what im saying.
I'll even ignore his home/road splits

actually, if i was able, i might take Tulo over both

Didn't you say Tulo sucks earlier in the year?

 

[cruzg24]

If Adrian Gonzalez was playing on a team like the Rockies or the Braves he would be the National Leagues MVP without a doubt.