1. How do you grade the Pistons signing of Chauncey Billups?
Patrick Hayes: A. It cant undo the past, but the fact remains Joe Dumars made a colossal mistake and I think hell admit as much, which is rare for a guy who is slow to admit mistakes when he traded Billups. Billups, and not Tayshaun Prince or Richard Hamilton, was the transitional talent the Pistons needed as Dumars undertook his stopping and starting slow rebuild over the last five years. Billups belongs in Detroit, he deserves to retire a Piston, and he actually still does a few things taking care of the ball, making 3s, running an offense decently enough to help fill some needs in a limited role for the team.
Dan Feldman: A-. Above all, Ill just really be happy to see Billups in the Pistons red, white and blue again. Detroits backcourt needed upgrading, and although hes the elite guard I dreamed of, hes an affordable option who can help. The Pistons might have slightly overpaid, but after paying Tayshaun Prince so much for his supposed leadership, at least theyre understanding they cant put such a premium on an intangible thats extremely difficult to predict.
Brady Fredericksen: A-. Whats the harm? The Pistons arent bringing him in to be a savior. Hopefully, they arent even bringing him in to be a real difference-maker. The Pistons have lacked plenty over the last few seasons, but leadership has been one of the biggest voids. Weve heard the Rodney Stuckey-is-a-Leader banter, and Greg Monroe doesnt really have the persona to be that vocal leader, but Billups has done it and can do it here. If he can come in, give 10-15 productive minutes every few nights and hit some (perhaps big) shots from the perimeter and be that coach on the floor and calming locker room presence its a worthwhile signing. Plus, The Palace is going to be bananas for the home opener with a big-name free agent and the return of a legend in Billups. Nostalgia for all.
