SI #5 QB

[Boda]

2013

QB's
#1 - Tom Brady
#2 - Aaron Rodgers
#3 - Peyton Manning
#4 - Drew Brees
#5 -
#6 -
#7 -
#8 -
#9 -
#10 -
 

 

[Boda]

Eli again

 

[Teagz]

Was down to Eli and Ryan for me. Tough choice but I went with Eli.

 

[Fuhgeddaboudit]

Eli Manning

 

[Wolves United]

This list has Aaron Rodgers at number 2? Shit list lel

 

[Fuhgeddaboudit]

This list has Aaron Rodgers at number 2? Shit list lel

 
It's very debatable between Rodgers and Brady. To me, I think it's tough to say Brady isn't the best QB right now. 

 

[A.E]

Eli's goofy-ass for me

 

[Soundwave]

Maybe have to go with Eli slightly ahead of Ben, but it is a big drop off from 4 to 5.

 

[jonathanlambert33]

Eli

 

[Fuhgeddaboudit]

Maybe have to go with Eli slightly ahead of Ben, but it is a big drop off from 4 to 5.

 
 
For me, it was tough to pick between the 2. Lately haven't liked how ben has been playing though. 

 

[Soundwave]

For me, it was tough to pick between the 2. Lately haven't liked how ben has been playing though.

Exactly. Consistency is what made the difference.

 

[BwareDWare94]

1. Rodgers
2. Brady
3. Manning
4. Brees
5. Eli
6. Ben
7. Flacco
8. Ryan
9. Romo
10. Schaub
 
Easy peasy list.

 

[Pugz]

[eli]te

 

[BwareDWare94]

Also, I place Flacco above of Ryan because Joe shows up in the playoffs and does quite a lot with lesser receiving options.

 

[Boda]

Also, I place Flacco above of Ryan because Joe shows up in the playoffs and does quite a lot with lesser receiving options.

I suggest you actually go look at Ryan's numbers this past offseason, If the Falcons would have won it all, everyone would be talking about how great he was in the playoffs just like they are with Flacco, only difference is Matt actually shows up during the regular season as well.  Flacco is just a bad QB who has had 1 good post season run.  Also lets not sell short Boldin, Smith & Rice

 

[Fuhgeddaboudit]

Flacco is too inconsistent outside of the playoffs. He wins a SB and everyone gets on his D.

 

[Boda]

Flacco is too inconsistent outside of the playoffs. He wins a SB and everyone gets on his D.

Exactly.  I still wouldn't let Flacco in the top 10.  He just isn't a good QB, atleast not yet, 1 Playoff run doesn't change that fact

 

[Giantmetfan07]

I actually came pretty close to picking Matt Ryan, but I just feel like I need to see a few more years of him to verify his consistency. I went with Eli, but I'm really surprised more votes didn't go to Ben or Ryan. 

 

[BwareDWare94]

I suggest you actually go look at Ryan's numbers this past offseason, If the Falcons would have won it all, everyone would be talking about how great he was in the playoffs just like they are with Flacco, only difference is Matt actually shows up during the regular season as well.  Flacco is just a bad QB who has had 1 good post season run.  Also lets not sell short Boldin, Smith & Rice

 
Flacco is not a bad QB by any means, and Matt Ryan finally had a good playoff game. Big deal. He blew two of his first three by himself.

 

[BwareDWare94]

Flacco is too inconsistent outside of the playoffs. He wins a SB and everyone gets on his D.

 
Inconsistent in what way, exactly? Sure he doesn't light it up every week, but he doesn't play poorly very often, either. It's rare. He might not throw TDs one week, but he ain't throwing picks either.
 
Matt Ryan can shit the bed on any given Sunday. You see that Oakland game last year? I don't recall Flacco having a game like that.