David Carr

[Arrial]

Now the 49ers have two of the most under achieving #1 overall picks the last decade or so.

I actually like the signing as long as we can get a decent RT in the draft, they should be able to protect the QB. If Smith gets hurt, I wouldn't mind seeing Carr gets some PT.

 

[jarrod2323]

living in Houston, 49ers shoulda stuck with Hill

 

[VC15]

Carr is a fine back-up, one of the best there is. But Hill probably should be the starter instead of Smith.

 

[Blake]

Smith > Carr > JaMarcus.

Not a bad sign at all.

 

[dez]

Carr is coming off his best year IMO

He was the worst QB to put on pads while in Carolina though...

 

[playmaker7]

living in Houston, 49ers shoulda stuck with Hill

Die

Smith was successful this year and thrived out of that spread offense

 

[tj#5]

He still has talent, but the problem is he can't be getting hit. In Houston, he had some decent games, but when everyone started labeling him a bust, was at the exact time that the Texans were breaking records for the most sacks allowed. The kid has had his brain rattled a lot, and the only way that he's every going to be able to play any kind of decent football would be with a good O-Line. As for playing with the 49ers, I think he could make some noise there. I doubt he turns out to be a guy that can be a starter for them, but if Smith does go down, I think he could fill in quite nicely for San Francisco.

 

[playmaker7]

I'm glad to have the guy as a backup but I'm hoping Smith takes every snap this season lol