Troy Polamalu vs. Ed Reed

[Mooche]

ED REED - BALTIMORE RAVENS

vs.

TROY POLAMALU - PITTSBURGH STEELERS

Who is the better all-around safety and why?
​

 

[footballplaya52]

we already did these two, but its reed for me. love his ballhawking.

 

[Mooche]

It's been a pretty damn long time. Last one turned into a flame-fest I believe anyways, so hopefully this can stir up some good debate and stay on topic.

 

[Blake]

Same as last time, Reed.

 

[Mooche]

Same as last time, Reed.

Some things don't ever change I guess, eh. I will still take Troy Polamalu over Ed Reed.

 

[.infamous]

Ill take troy

 

[jonathanlambert33]

Troy

 

[Hurricane Season]

Some things don't ever change I guess, eh. I will still take Troy Polamalu over Ed Reed.

The last thread was in January though, lol. IDK how someones opinion could change over the course of one offseason.

 

[Mooche]

The last thread was in January though, lol. IDK how someones opinion could change over the course of one offseason.

My bad.

 

[Hurricane Season]

That being said, I don't know why this debate continues so often. You just can't compare the two because they are completely different players, playing two different positions.

Maybe you can argue who makes the bigger impact at their position, but both make an impact in different areas. Polamalu excels in run support, he's the superior tackler and is overall a little more versatile while Reed has superior field vision, and is the best ball hawk in the league. Both play their assignments to perfection. You really can't go wrong with either choice.

 

[kam.]

LOL.

Troy = SS
ED = FS.

Why compare?

SMFH.. Dumbassshit.

Lets compare Revis to Ed Reed next.

 

[Mooche]

LOL.

Troy = SS
ED = FS.

Why compare?

SMFH.. Dumbassshit.

Lets compare Revis to Ed Reed next.

It's obviously comparing the players in a type of "who would you rather have?" or "who is the better talent?" type of fashion.

No need to be a stuck up dick for me posting a pretty good question. STFU.

 

[kam.]

It's obviously comparing the players in a type of "who would you rather have?" or "who is the better talent?" type of fashion.

No need to be a stuck up dick for me posting a pretty good question. STFU.

You mad as fuck bro.

 

[Da Bulls]

Troy

 

[TTN2810]

Don't spam old thread dude..

 

[Hurricane Season]

I wish Mooche would come back tho.