Best Division Of QBs?

RipCity32 · Jul 6, 2012

Got the idea off NFL Live. We may have already had a thread like this, but I'm not sure.
Basically, who do you guys think has the best division of QBS?

elcheato · Jul 6, 2012

NFC East barely over the NFC North, just because they don't have any weak links quite like Ponder.

bosoxlover12 · Jul 6, 2012

I said the NFC South.

Brees-Ryan-Freeman-Killa Cam

RipCity32 · Jul 6, 2012

For me, I take NFC North barely over NFC East. Solely because RGIII has never played a snap in the NFL yet. However, I will change my opinion at the end of the year if RGIII is as good as advertised.

Rice18 · Jul 6, 2012

Rodgers, Cutler, Stafford are all top 10 QBs.

Ponder was a rookie last year, this year will be judgement time.

Falcons11497 · Jul 6, 2012

NFC South
Brees is elite, Ryan is getting there, Cam had an awesome year, and Freeman

Hurricane Season · Jul 6, 2012

ITT: Whatever division my team plays for.

RipCity32 · Jul 6, 2012

Nah, we just have a lot of fans from the 3 divisions that would actually deserve winning lol. All the other divisions aren't on the same level.

Hurricane Season · Jul 6, 2012

Yeah.

It basically comes down to who you think is the best out of Ponder, Freeman or Griffin (two of which are unproven). The rest of the QB's in those three divisions are legit top 15 QBs.

TTN2810 · Jul 7, 2012

In three years, AFC South will be in contention, with Luck, Locker, Gabbert(?), and whoever the Texans have, possibly maybe TJ Yates.

Right now though, like Jake said it's pretty well a tie with the 3 divisions, but I personally would take out the NFC South from consideration.

RipCity32 · Jul 7, 2012

Yeah, NFC South really shouldn't be mentioned.
Way I see it though...

Rodgers = Brees
Stafford > Ryan
Cutler > Newton
Ponder < Freeman

Rodgers > Manning
Stafford > Romo
Cutler = Vick
Ponder < Griffin

WHO-DEY-BENGALS_18 · Jul 7, 2012

I'll take Tony Romo, Michael Vick, Eli Manning & RG3.

NFC East

bosoxlover12 · Jul 7, 2012

RipCity32 said:
Yeah, NFC South really shouldn't be mentioned.
Way I see it though...

Rodgers = Brees
Stafford > Ryan
Cutler > Newton
Ponder < Freeman

but if you numerically grade them

Rodgers= 10
Brees = 10
Stafford=8.5
Ryan= 8
Cutler= 8.5
Newton= 8
Ponder = 4
Freeman= 6.5

Combined score of the NFC South>North

bosoxlover12 · Jul 7, 2012

Eli= 9
Romo= 8.5
Vick = 8
rg3= 6 (generous grade as a rookie)

South>west

BwareDWare94 · Jul 7, 2012

RipCity32 said:
Yeah, NFC South really shouldn't be mentioned.
Way I see it though...

Rodgers = Brees
Stafford > Ryan
Cutler > Newton
Ponder < Freeman

Rodgers > Manning
Stafford > Romo- That right there is the only one you got wrong. Otherwise, way to sum it up
Cutler = Vick
Ponder < Griffin

BwareDWare94 · Jul 7, 2012

701 said:
Rodgers, Cutler, Stafford are all top 10 QBs.

Ponder was a rookie last year, this year will be judgement time.

Not just yet.

The East wins with 3 established top 15 QBs and two Established top 10s in Eli and Romo. Top 7, actually.

bosoxlover12 · Jul 7, 2012

So Romo is Top 7, but Stafford and Cutler aren't top 10?? lulz

Falcons11497 · Jul 7, 2012

jesus christ, do you ever hop off romos dick?
Stafford>Romo any day
I still would personally take Ryan>Romo, and Vick>Romo as well

bosoxlover12 · Jul 7, 2012

Eh, I'd take Romo over Vick and Ryan, but he still way overrates him

BwareDWare94 · Jul 7, 2012

bosoxlover12 said:
So Romo is Top 7, but Stafford and Cutler aren't top 10?? lulz

Nah, I guess I'd put Stafford in the top 10, but not Cutler

Best Division Of QBs?

Which Division Has The Best QBs?

NFC East

NFC North

NFC South

NFC West

AFC East

AFC North

AFC South

AFC West

King Of The East

Well-Known Member

We're Onto Cincinnati

King Of The East

I'm emotionally vested in me.

LEGENDARY.

Well-Known Member

King Of The East

Well-Known Member

New Member

King Of The East

Well-Known Member

We're Onto Cincinnati

We're Onto Cincinnati

Where were you when the world stopped turning?

Where were you when the world stopped turning?

We're Onto Cincinnati

LEGENDARY.

We're Onto Cincinnati

Where were you when the world stopped turning?

Users Who Are Viewing This Thread (Users: 0, Guests: 1)

Tampa Bay Rays (Away)

Houston Astros (Home)