Tony Romo vs. Eli Manning

Which QB would you take today for your team?

Fucking neither

Eli is a pick-magnet, and Romo isn't a team leader IMO

bosoxlover12 said:

Fucking neither

Eli is a pick-magnet, and Romo isn't a team leader IMO

Click to expand...

A lot of Eli's picks are balls that are right in the receivers hands but are hit up instead of being caught. Eli gets a bad rep as someone who throws tons of picks when he's not as bad as people say.

Jesus, I guess I'll say Eli. I'm not a fan of either though.

Took Homo

I'd go with Eli, cause he's related to Peyton.

Marcus Jordan = Greatest basketball play of all-time

Why? Because he's Michael Jordan's son

My god you're foolish

Tony Romo. I think he's better than what most people give him credit for. Same thing could be said about Eli Manning, however. I'll take Romo though.

Bleacher Creature said:

Marcus Jordan = Greatest basketball play of all-time

Why? Because he's Michael Jordan's son

My god you're foolish

Click to expand...

lol your foolish. What does this how to do with being great at all????? I take Eli cause I hate the cowboys and I think Eli is better.

Blake said:

Jesus, I guess I'll say Eli. I'm not a fan of either though.

Click to expand...

+1

Eli in a heartbeat. Long run wise, he is so much better

Eli Manning has a Super Bowl ring, enough said. lol, not really.

Eli has atleast had a very good playoff run, Romo hasnt.

I dislike both being in the East Div, but I surely wouldn't pick Romo.

Now that he's married, the effect of "Homo" seems not to work anymore

But yes, Eli between the two.

Eli:

- Younger
- More durable
- Superbowl MVP
- Plays in the biggest market under constant scrutiny
- Plays with multiple WR's who have drop/tipped ball issues
- 14 career fourth quarter comebacks
- 17 game winning drives

Yeah.

Haven't you always said how the Giants have one of the best WR cores in the NFL, but now they're full of guys with the drop disease?

Domerocker13 said:

Eli:

- Younger
- More durable
- Superbowl MVP
- Plays in the biggest market under constant scrutiny
- Plays with multiple WR's who have drop/tipped ball issues
- 14 career fourth quarter comebacks
- 17 game winning drives

Yeah.

Click to expand...

- Has led the NFL in interceptions.
- Averages a pick a game.
- Romo ranks fourth all time in yards-per-attempt.
- Romo averages less interceptions per contest, not by much though.
- Are you really saying that, football wise, Manning is under more scrutiny in New York?
- Romo has thrown more than 15 picks in a season just once, Manning has accomplished the feat four times.
- That defensive line deserved the MVP, and you know damn well that Manning wasn't the most deserving player.
- Fun fact; the year that Manning won the Super Bowl, that offense had more than three turnovers in a game five times.
- The year the Giants won the Super Bowl, Manning also fumbled the ball 13 times.

Just saying.

- Has led the NFL in interceptions.

Click to expand...

Playing half of your games in blustery Giants Stadium every year will do that.

- Averages a pick a game.

Click to expand...

Most of those picks come early in the games. He's normally at his best later on, when it really counts. This is proven by his number of game winning drives and fourth quarter comebacks.

- Romo ranks fourth all time in yards-per-attempt.

Click to expand...

How many post-season wins has that given him? Isn't that how we judge quarterbacks.

- Are you really saying that, football wise, Manning is under more scrutiny in New York?

Click to expand...

Yes. The NY Media is notorious for criticizing New York celebrities over everything.

- Romo has thrown more than 15 picks in a season just once, Manning has accomplished the feat four times.

Click to expand...

He plays most of his games in sunny Texas. Not in the northeast with some of the harshest conditions of any stadium.

- That defensive line deserved the MVP, and you know damn well that Manning wasn't the most deserving player.

Click to expand...

Did Eli give up a fourth quarter lead? Did the defense engineer two scoring drives in the fourth quarter? I thought so. He won the award, end of story,

- Fun fact; the year that Manning won the Super Bowl, that offense had more than three turnovers in a game five times.

Click to expand...

The team was pretty mediocre during the regular season. That is no secret. However, they only turned the ball over once during that post-season run. The regular season should never be a final indicator of a team's success.

- The year the Giants won the Super Bowl, Manning also fumbled the ball 13 times.

Click to expand...

Romo hasn't exactly been too stellar in that department either.

Your biased posts are hilarious to read.

Domerocker13 said:

Playing half of your games in blustery Giants Stadium every year will do that.


Most of those picks come early in the games. He's normally at his best later on, when it really counts. This is proven by his number of game winning drives and fourth quarter comebacks.

Click to expand...

I stopped reading after this.

Eli had 16 of his 25 interceptions on the road.

8 of his 25 interceptions came in the fourth quarter of games last season. He also had his lowest completion % of any quarter in the fourth, least yards, and lowest QB rating.

When playing with a lead, Manning had 13 TD and 8 INT. When trailing or tied... 18 TD and 17 INT.

Yankees2772 said:

I stopped reading after this.

Eli had 16 of his 25 interceptions on the road.

8 of his 25 interceptions came in the fourth quarter of games last season. He also had his lowest completion % of any quarter in the fourth, least yards, and lowest QB rating.

When playing with a lead, Manning had 13 TD and 8 INT. When trailing or tied... 18 TD and 17 INT.

Click to expand...

We're only talking about last season? That was an anomaly. I'll admit that he wasn't too great in the 4th last year. At least check the other years as well, since we are going off of careers.